
"Luchana", 30 Years of a Tragedy
Recently, thirty years have passed since the tragic sinking of the Spanish ship “Luchana”, which claimed the lives of three crew members. It happened on January 15, 1986, at the beginning of a fateful year for seafarers. Three others went missing and two more were added to the list of seven lost ships, including the bulk carrier “Castillo de Salas”, the fishing vessels “Terín” and “Pico Pienzu”, also Spanish; the yachts “Green Flash” and “Under Repair” and the bulk carrier “Stanley Bay”, registered in Hong Kong.
The last voyage of the ship “Luchana”, owned by Naviera Bilbaína, began on January 11, 1986, when it left the port of Almería with a cargo of 13,400 tons of iron ore for the Ensidesa factory in Avilés. On board were 25 crew members under the command of Captain José Fabra Vila and two accompanying family members. On the afternoon of January 15, with bad weather in the Cantabrian Sea and when it was less than three miles from its destination port, contact was established with the pilot station, which indicated that it should postpone the entry maneuver until the next tide.
To weather the storm, the captain ordered a northwest course. At 18:10, it was on a heading of 130º and bearing 2.5 miles from the Cabo Peñas lighthouse, enduring violent rolling. An hour later, it was about six miles away on the same bearing, and then began the beginning of the end, as researcher Manuel Rodríguez Aguilar recounts in his article titled “The Tragedy of the Luchana”.
“… a loud noise was heard at the bow of the bridge, at the height of hold number 4, like a kind of ‘crack’, accompanied by a strange tremor. Simultaneously, the main engine stopped. The captain immediately ordered the deck lights to be turned on, observing that ‘…the water was flooding the deck at the height of holds number 2 and 3, while the bow and stern began to rise towards the center and mineral began to spill over the sides’. There was not much to be done for a ship that had just split in two, but there was much to do for the people on board. Therefore, the captain ordered a distress message to be sent while also ordering the abandonment of the ship. Its approximate position was: latitude 43º 39.5’N and longitude 06º 03.5’W. The distress message was picked up around 19:15 by Peñas Radio, which immediately alerted the ships navigating in the area.”
When the emergency was known, the tugboats “Nieva”, “Adelantado”, and “Arañón” set sail from the port of Avilés, along with several fishing boats and a Red Cross boat. The Spanish bulk carrier “Marcoverde” changed course to head to the site of the disaster. Meanwhile, on board, the captain had ordered the abandonment of the ship. Everyone, wearing their life jackets, headed for the lifeboat deck, except for the chief engineer, Félix Frúñiz Urrutia, the first officer, José Ignacio García Zarandona, and the second officer, Fernando Iglesias López, who went to the engine room, as Manuel Rodríguez Aguilar recounts,
“it seems that their intention was to close the fuel valves in order to prevent possible fires and keep the lights on to facilitate the rescue of their companions. The weather continued to be very bad and it was raining heavily. The lowering of the port lifeboat (a couple of rafts were also launched that escaped due to the force of the sea) was done with seven people on board, and as soon as they hit the water, it began to roll violently and separate from the side of the ship. The rest of the crew was on the deck holding onto various handholds and waiting for the moment to jump into the water. When the moment came, there was no choice but to jump into a raging sea, leaving three heroes working in the engine room on board. They had to swim to reach the lifeboat, but the waves made it an impossible mission. Nevertheless, little by little, almost all were picked up by their companions, while the ‘Luchana’ tilted at the bow and sank in just fifteen minutes without completely breaking in two. The lifeboat had no oars and its engine refused to start, so the time the freezing castaways had to endure before their rescue became painful and endless.”
The fishing vessel “Llorca Primero” spotted two flares and rescued 21 occupants from a boat, including some injured, heading to Avilés. The longliner “La Austera”, based in Cudillero, and the tugboat “Nieva” rescued three more people, with the help of the Spanish bulk carrier “Marcoverde”, one very seriously injured, the bosun, Abel Santiago Brión, who died shortly after; the wife of the chief engineer and a sailor, all showing signs of drowning.[1]
The next day, the search for the three missing persons was suspended, as it was believed that the engineers had been trapped in the engine room and the chances of finding them were practically nil. Criticism poured in for the scant rescue resources available. An investigation commission promoted by the General Directorate of Merchant Marine determined that the disaster was attributed to poor stowage of the cargo and also acknowledged that there was a lack of control in loading and unloading operations. The remains of the ship “Luchana” rest at a depth of 95 m at position 43º 40.9’N and 006º 02.2’W.
We have read other interesting and enlightening details provided by someone who claims to have been on watch in command of the tugboat “Adelantado” on January 15, 1986, and who publishes on the blog naufragosdelamar.com under the pseudonym “botavara”:
“On January 15, 1986, I was on watch in command of the tugboat ‘Adelantado’. At approximately 17:30, the pilot on watch (Mr. Emilio Panizo) called for two tugboats to go out and assist the ship ‘Luchana’. When we were outside the bar of Avilés, it was observed that there was NW sea, with a cross swell from the N.
The pilot boat remained at the entrance and told the captain of the ‘Luchana’ that the docking at Ensidesa was occupied and to leave it anchored in the Endasa dock, it would be brought in at the next tide.
With the tugboat ‘Adelantado’, we approached to less than 0.5 miles from the ‘Luchana’, which was less than a mile NW of the Avilés lighthouse. The weather was calming down and the entrance to the bar posed no danger. When we were entering, I noticed that the ‘Luchana’ was heading W with little power. When we were having dinner, we received a call from the pilot on watch, to go out and assist the Luchana that was sinking.
Two tugboats, ‘Nieva’ and ‘Adelantado’, went out. Later, ‘Arañón’ also set out. When we arrived at the sinking area, a large part of the crew of the ‘Luchana’ had already been picked up by the fishing vessel ‘Llorca Primero’. We picked up two crew members who were in the raft, and the chief engineer’s wife was in the water with a life jacket.
We spent the whole night circling the area until the next morning when we returned to port. Some time later, I met a crew member from the Luchana. He told me that they had been pumping water for more than half an hour while the ship drifted away from the coast.
Ships don’t break apart for no reason. Everything has an explanation.
The story is as follows: The ship heads W, little power, much relaxation. After a while, a crack, with the sea breaking, a shoal under the keel. The Petón (breaks with NW sea), located NE of Cabo Vidrias, between Isla Deva and Faro de Avilés. It heads N to quickly distance itself from the coast while the pumping system is activated. After a while, it is observed that the water ingress is very large and cannot be pumped out. Night falls, lights must be given to launch the lifeboats, and while the engineers are in the engine room, the ship sinks.”
The truth is that the “Luchana” was an aging ship. Construction number 155 from the Euskalduna shipyard in Bilbao, the keel was laid on February 22, 1963, and on July 19 of the same year, it slid down the slipway with the customary ceremony. It entered service on January 7, 1964, as a general cargo ship, compartmentalized into five holds, four of them forward of the superstructure, and a complement of eight five-ton stanchions and a crane for heavy weights of 30 tons.
With a gross tonnage of 8,250 tons, a net tonnage of 5,576 tons, and a deadweight of 14,524 tons, it measured 144.71 m in overall length -134.45 m between perpendiculars-, 18.65 m in beam, 11.99 m in depth, and 9.63 m in draft. In five holds, it could carry 18,793 cubic meters of grain. It was powered by a MAN engine, with 5,400 horsepower, allowing it to maintain a speed of 14 knots. IMO Code 5416474.
In 1969, it was chartered by Marasia on the Far East line, and in 1972 it was converted into a “bulk carrier”. The work was carried out at the AESA shipyard in Olaveaga and was later repeated on the ship “Las Arenas”, of the same type and registration.
In April 1981, a very serious breakdown occurred while sailing in ballast from Arguineguín (Gran Canaria) to Jacksonville (USA), in the midst of a storm, resulting in a crack between holds number 1 and 2. Upon arrival, the Coast Guard and Lloyd’s issued negative reports, and it was prohibited from leaving port under its own power, even after repairs, so it was towed to Bilbao on a journey filled with difficulties due to the prevailing bad weather.
On May 25, 1981, it arrived in Bilbao, and although scrapping was the initial intention of the management of Naviera Bilbaína, it was decided to repair it at the La Naval factory in Sestao, where it was located when in July it suffered a fire that caused serious damage. The works concluded at the end of August, and after passing official inspections, it was moored awaiting orders.
In October 1985, during a voyage from Paranaguá (Brazil) to Tarragona and Sevilla with a grain cargo, a fire broke out in the engine room, which was extinguished with the means available on board, although they were about to abandon it. The ship then headed to Almería, which would be the beginning of its last voyage.
Bibliography:
“The Tragedy of the “Luchana”, by Manuel Rodríguez Aguilar. Our gratitude.
Note:
[1] El País, January 17, 1986.




